Merit Network
Can't find what you're looking for? Search the Mail Archives.
  About Merit   Services   Network   Resources & Support   Network Research   News   Events   Home

Discussion Communities: Merit Network Email List Archives

North American Network Operators Group

Date Prev | Date Next | Date Index | Thread Index | Author Index | Historical

2006.06.06 Net Optics Learning Center Presents Passive Monitoring Access

  • From: Matthew Petach
  • Date: Fri Jun 09 00:21:16 2006
  • Domainkey-signature: a=rsa-sha1; q=dns; c=nofws; s=beta; d=gmail.com; h=received:message-id:date:from:sender:to:subject:mime-version:content-type:content-transfer-encoding:content-disposition:x-google-sender-auth; b=HbxMlE6V4EZBnGSHKAA1Ule0BpDnFlrrp3FgAOdUvLTajQ2SxAhCKU9WBPF6II7txyJtKT10/Drr4o5PFO9gkOdAEHHcpTOE8BMoHGFsJTEObRQyPvbi6WncRut7MBIk3ZiVkzBEWOFwfzy5l02PrRVrxQCvWTYX42cpLn/jDFg=

(apologies, this really was just a marketing presentation
in very, very thin disguise.  I really want that hour of my
life back.  :(  --Matt )

2006.06.06 Net Optics Learning Center Presents
The fundamentals of Passive Monitoring Access
[slides are at:
http://www.nanog.org/mtg-0606/pdf/joy-weber.pdf

TAP technology--tools change, but some things
stay somewhat constant--need a way to collect
information.
Port contention for monitoring--how many people
are running into these issues?
How many people use SPAN ports to get access
to information?

Agenda:
Present an overview of Tap technology and how it
makes network monitoring and security devices
more effective and efficient.

tap technology overview
taps, port aggregators, and regen taps
active response, bypass switches
link aggregators and matrix switches
taps with intelligence

Add more intelligence, SNMP capability into
remote tap systems.

passive monitoring access--you should have full
access to 100% of the packet data; even errors,
etc. at layer 1 and layer 2.

passive means without affecting traffic
no latency
no IP addresses
no packets added, dropped, or manipulated
No link failure

traffic can be collected via:
hubs
optical taps

What is zero delay?
eliminates delays caused by the 10msec delay
found in most taps when the tap loses power.

Zero Delay means if the tap loses power
no packets dropped/resent
no latency introduced
power loss to tap undetectable in the network

Hubs are cheap and easy, get most of the info
you need.  The more utilization, the higher
the collision rate means you're not getting all
the data you need.

Placing devices in-line; you get full visibility,
but requires impact when you need to move monitoring
tool from one place to another, or work on the
tool.
advantage: see all traffic including layer 1 and 2 errs
preserve full duplex links

SPAN ports--gain access to data, internal to a switch;
good for data internal to switch fabric.  But you lose
layer1 and layer2 errs; not so bad for security tools,
but for network debugging, horrible.
Only supports seeing data flowing through a
single switch.
fights over who gets access to the port for tools.

Test Access Ports (TAP)
designed to duplicate traffic for monitoring devices.

You put it inline once, it's inline, passive.  preserves
full duplex links, device neutral, can be installed
between any 2 devices.
remains passive
no failure point introduced

fiber taps don't even require power.
always need to fail through, no interruption.

creates a permanent access port to the data
stream.

copper and fiber handled differently;
copper has a retransmit system to replicate
the information; fiber, just splits photon
streams.

Two output ports, only transmitting data;
no way to send data back through.
No way to introduce errors.

Different types:
single tap: duplicates link traffic for a monitoring
 device
regeneration tap: duplicates link traffic for multiple
 monitoring devices
link aggregator tap: combines traffic from multiple
 links
matrix switches: offer software-control access to
 multiple links
other tap options:
 built-in media conversion--use mismatched interfaces
  without separate media converter
active response--inject responses back into the link.

converter taps serve two purposes--connect dissimilar
interfaces without media converter.  but usually
don't fail through cleanly.

Active response is generally in the security arena.
sends back to both sides.

Copper tap devices
10/100baseT
10/100/1000baseT triple speed
1000baseT normal gig tap

Need TWO monitoring NICs to see full duplex data, since
you get TWO TX links coming at you.

Try to get triple speed TAP with dip switch
speed/flow setting, rather than trying to autosense.

Fiber taps
gigabit
SX/LX/SZ,
10gig
SR/LR/ER (multimode and single mode)

still has 2 TX outputs.

topology, and split ratio
split ratio is amount of light going to each
port.

split ratio--amount of light you're willing to
tolerate giving up on the network port.
Basically, work up a Loss Power budget for the
link, figure out how much you can afford to lose
before you lose link.

Need to make sure that there will be no impact
for either end!

Do you take distance between the monitoring device
and the tap output device?  Yes, try to keep within
the reduced power budget available off the monitor
port, usually about 10 meters should be fine.

Can you re-use optical taps for OC12 ATM
as well as gigE or 10gigE?

will be specific for multimode vs single mode,
if you stay at 50/50, generally not a problem.

Converter taps are generally powered.  the primary
path is passive, but the monitoring port has to be
active to support the media conversion.

Port aggregator taps
full duplex link being tapped, aggregating out a single
link so you don't need 2 NICs to capture the TX data.

can also make a port a full duplex, 2 way active/passive
port in newer models.

what about multiple output ports?  allow passive
access for multiple monitoring devices to a single
through port.

regeneration taps go all the way up to 10gig at the
moment.

SPAN regeneration taps slightly different; that
assumes you're off a SPAN port; dual-span, two sets
of data flow.  Non-aggregated, two independent sets of
ports.
Primarily used for cases where multiple devices
need access to the wire.

Initial costs of TAPs is generally the only major
downside.
Aggregation taps are same type, but monitor via a
single NIC


Active response and bypass switches.
ability to inject data back into the network.
can set *one* monitor port to bidirectional mode.

Bypass switches--allow devices to be inserted
*inline* without breaking fiber path or copper
path.  It can watch for heartbeat packet, electrical
or optical signal coming through, and if the inline
device drops, the router ports are passed through
to each other.  Good for IPS devices.
Generally available with a heartbeat packet that it
watches for; device just needs to be able to receive
and pass through heartbeat packet.

Q: from audience--how fast does it switch over?
10msec when heartbeat fails.
Q: and how fast is the heartbeat packet?
A: Should be configurable down to one second.
If it doesn't recieve 3 in a row, goes into bypass
mode.
So really 3 second failover.

Also check to make sure they're certified with
your vendor!

power-only bypass switch vs heartbeat detection.
the power-only one just shares the same power cord
as the IPS device; pretty much a kludge.

Link Aggregators

Span link aggregator taps
usually 10/100/1000; not much push for fiber
aggregators yet.
take multiple span ports, collect to a single
pair of monitoring ports.

One thing to watch out for with link aggregator
taps is to make sure you don't oversubscribe
your ports through to the monitoring port!

Can also to get link aggregation tap with
regeneration, to take several fiber paths,
aggregate to copper monitoring devices.

Matrix switches give access to multiple
ports

inline and span matrix ports.

inline matrix switch use passive tap on
the front-end; multiple passive ports,
monitoring port gets to pick which ones
you're monitoring from.

ethernet ports, snmp traps, send traps to
monitoring station for specific stats, coming out
as next hot thing.

Common, central monitoring point.
Useful to have software controlling matrix
switch so you can look at different ports at
different times.
front-end still passive, monitor ports need
to be active.

SPAN matrix switches--give you access to multiple
network switch SPAN ports.  Can daisychain ports
if necessary.
Highest density usually 8 or 16 passive inline
ports for the most part.
SPAN works a bit differently, you can get about
96 SPAN port visibility by chaining them together,
master/slave relationship.

software is key, need to make sure the software
serves your purpose of roaming across links.

TAPs with intelligence and remote access.
how do you turn off monitor ports, how do you
see what peak traffic level was?  Less passive,
more active device.
intelligent taps usually have a display screen
on them, shows A and B side peak utilization.

can disable ports remotely, turn off display in
a datacenter, etc.

main features:
realtime utilization levels for each side of link
traffic
size and time of the greatest traffic peaks
SNMP traps for system, link, power, and threshold
counters for total packets, bytes, CRC errors,
 collisions, and more
status for system, link, and power

Security and Control
Turn off management and monitor ports
set utilization alarm thresholds
reset statistics

basically, add more intelligence into the
network, abeit with passive front-side tap.

senior technical specialist
joy@netoptics.com
www.netoptics.com
ts-support@netoptics.com

Time for dinner!  Wraps up at 1736 hours Pacific Time.




Discussion Communities


About Merit | Services | Network | Resources & Support | Network Research
News | Events | Contact | Site Map | Merit Network Home


Merit Network, Inc.