North American Network Operators Group|
Date Prev | Date Next |
Date Index |
Thread Index |
Author Index |
Re: who offers cheap (personal) 1U colo?
- From: Andrew Dorsett
- Date: Sun Mar 14 01:32:06 2004
On Sun, 14 Mar 2004, Sean Donelan wrote:
> I think the actual requirement is for a long-term end-to-end identifier
> for systems, and maybe even network users, before they can do certain
> activities on the network so you can trace or block the system. Systems
Now my question becomes....Is this an identifier that other providers can
use to trace the machine, or only for the local isp. I look at it this
way. If I'm the provider I don't really care what username they are, I can
determine their location by the logs. Sure they may be a DSL, but they
will at some point request an address. When they request an address I have
their circuit ID and I can at least narrow it down to a house or
> A student in a college dorm room with an uncontrolled DHCP address may not
> be able to run a server, even though they have more than enough symetric
> Gig-ethernet bandwidth and you know what dorm it is physically located
> because all student servers look alike. On the other hand, a mobile
This is a topic I get very soap-boxish about. I have too many problems
with providers who don't understand the college student market. I can
think of one university who requires students to login through a web
portal before giving them a routable address. This is such a waste of
time for both parties. Sure it makes tracking down the abusers much
easier, but is it worth the time and effort to manage? This is a very
legitimate idea for public portals in common areas, but not in dorm rooms.
In a dorm room situation or an apartment situation, you again know the
physical port the DHCP request came in on. You then know which room that
port is connected to and you therefore have a general idea of who the
abuser is. So whats the big deal if you turn off the ports to the room
until the users complain and the problem is resolved?
I guess this requires very detailed cable map databases and is something
some providers are relunctant to develop. Scary thought.....
Cisco Certified Network Associate
"Learn from the mistakes of others. You won't live long enough to make all of them yourself."