North American Network Operators Group|
Date Prev | Date Next |
Date Index |
Thread Index |
Author Index |
Re: rfc 1918?
- From: John Hawkinson
- Date: Thu Feb 22 17:46:27 2001
> > > There are good reasons to want to get those packets (traceroutes from
> > > people who have numbered their networks in rfc1918 networks,
> No John, there are exactly zero reasons, good or otherwise, for allowing
> any traffic with RFC-1918 source addresses to traverse any part of the
> public Internet. Period! :-)
You are being religious, and I shall not descend into this sort of
discussion with you. It is simply non productive nor professional.
I disagree, and believe that other reasonable people do so as well,
and there is therefore argument over this issue. People should not
assert canonicity upon it. End of story.